Firstly let me say how much I enjoy OCTGN and I'm currently a subscriber. However the new chat implementation has caused such a shake-up of game flow and usability that makes it very awkward for me to use. From the main chat lobby I see there has been a lot of consternation from a lot of other users regarding the changes as well.
Firstly as I'm colourblind I find it very hard to read, the chat box needs to be on an opaque background (or an option to change it).
I appreciate that removing the chat box from the bottom UI has given more room to display cards (wasn't really an issue in Netrunner before and I even raised an issue on github to enable me to drag the chatbox horizontally again before that got changed). However that new horizontal bar (magenta shaded area) along the top has taken away some of the vertical space of the play area which is what I've been trying to get more of (the main reason I subscribed and play in fullscreen mode coincidentally). There is lots of dead space at the side of the play area for Netrunner. This would be the perfect spot to have a chat / event log. (Large yellow shaded area).
Ignoring the fact the (magenta) scrolling log thing is unreadable which is easily fixed giving it an opaque background. Having it take up more vertical space means I would have to zoom the play area back out a bit making everything smaller. I was about to start recording and streaming games. Having things smaller is bad for the viewers, one of the stated reasons for this chat change was to create more playing space, though you can clearly see that it has done the opposite.
Lets compare the way I've got it set up without the subscription banner, fullscreen and no taskbar vs someone who has the banner, not playing fullscreen (so larger menu) and a visible taskbar.
This screenshot comparison should show you how taking up more of the vertical space is a detriment to the UI and playing area (at least for Netrunner).
There are other issues with not having a visible chat/event log is that it helps with both game flow and also being social when playing. I play other board games online using other platforms and spend a lot of time chatting with my friends/other players. Having it visible all the time is great for this and adds to the enjoyment of the game, at least for me.
Having the events log viewable also helps with game flow as both players can easily see how many credits are used for boosting strength and breaking subroutines when using icebreakers. Having to pop the log up every time someone passes a piece of ICE is going to make the game much more convoluted and slower.
I saw some people suggest having two separate logs with only one visible full time. I'm personally against doing this as being able to chat in line with the event log is one of the best way to teach new players if you don't have voice comms (which is nearly every game I've played). Being able to explain inline what's going on is a massive help.
Lastly a personal bugbear of the new chat box is that it puts new lines at the top rather than at the bottom like before. As a long time user of IRC (as demonstrated in the main OCTGN lobby) I'm used to things scrolling from the bottom when it comes to chat. It seems odd having it scroll from the top when most of the main card UI is all at the bottom of the screen. I hardly ever use the top menu for anything beyond perhaps resetting the game. I spend more time looking at the bottom area of the screen than the top and that's also where the chat input box is. When having a convo, typing what you are saying at the bottom and then glancing up for the responses seems a bit awkward compared to having to just look one line up. I could live with it scrolling from the top but not having them displayed on screen where there is plenty of space to have a permanently visible one (for Netrunner) is a big step backwards in usability. From the reaction of other players in the main chat it seems I am not alone.
I do hope you take these points on board going forwards. The one issue it would create is that when you hover over cards and get a larger version of them. With having the chat in that area on the left, it would make sense if the large card image hover always came up on the right. This was what was stopping me from previously just dragging the old chat box vertically upwards all the way to the top (that and the translucent background).
EDIT: Oh one other thing is that is awkward with having it disappearing / reappearing is that it is set to use the ESC key. For Netrunner I use that fairly often to jack out of a run. If I start chatting mid run and then try to get rid of the box I can accidentally jack out of a run if the focus isn't on the box (this is easily done). While db0 could reassign jacking out to another key, it is actually a really useful key to use ESC for that function. While not having the chat box visible as I explained actually makes OCTGN less usable (for me).
I agree with all your points. I'm not colorblind so that doesn't impact me. I agree with all your other points. I only play ANR on OCTN so this feedback pertains to that game only.
-Having the chat "bounce" with each new line is nerve-racking.
-Having the chat in the middle of the board is also untenable.
-There are many interactions between players (esp. during runs) that require the chat to be more visible. While the "line" of recent text just above players' hands it wasn't readable it could address some of these issues. It was magenta for Explosive but it was white for me. The text was virtually invisible. A quick change would be to make the background on the bar a solid color (not transparent) that differs from the text color.
-By far the most irritating is that it's so small and in the middle of the table. Ugh.
-I also think the most recent lines should appear at the bottom rather than the top.
-Putting the chat window to the side for ANR may not work for other games but that could be solved by allowing users to move it and resize it based on preferences.
Thanks for listening/reading.
I coloured it in magenta in my screenshot to make it clear what I was talking about (like I coloured the yellow area to refer to where I think would be a good place to put it), it was practically transparent with a tiny white gradient in the the actual client.
Good point about what works for Netrunner may not work for other games. I don't know how possible it would be to have it in different places set by the game coder (in our case db0). Obviously having it moveable would let every user set it as they prefer.
Different games may also not require use of a chat/event log box as much as others, I don't think there is a one size fits all, but the current changes for me personally put me off playing.
The new chat is a nightmare. Having to hit enter and clutter up the center of the play area to chat, not being able to move that box, and having the chat bar completely unreadable. It made runs very confusing, it was a mess trying to figure out what was going on when you had to keep hitting enter to bring up box, catch up with the bouncing/upside down chat box, then hit esc (but be careful you weren't on the field when you hit esc so you don't jack out) to get the box out of the way so you could target the next item.
I liked the new sounds, I like the new look. I hate, hate, hate all the deadspace on the screen combined with the terrible chat interface and totally unreadable event bar. As was pointed out before, opaque for the chat bar, and at the very least get rid of the bouncing, upside down lines in the chat window and let us reposition it.
Add my name to the list. Up until now, my biggest problem with the chat box has been that the shortcut keys don't work when it has focus (you needed to manually click out of the chat before hitting F1/F12 for example).
I get that this is a "work in progress" and that it's leading to something else, but to have to take such a drastic leap back in functionality for some un-mentioned future benefit is understandably frustrating for the users.
Whatever the future plans are, here's my idea of what needs to happen to make the current changes usable:
1. The chat box NEEDS to be movable/re sizable. Preferably with a docking option.
2. The chat "ticker" needs to be configurable so that it is readable regardless of the background. If it a subscriber perk to be able to use custom backgrounds, but the ticker is only legible when the background is black, it's not really much of a perk at all, is it?
3. Make sure the shortcut keys can fire regardless of what has focus. If I hit F1 or F12 it should start/end my turn no matter what.
My two cents.
Going to give my opinion here.
The new chat is horrific.
I've cancelled runs trying to close the chat box. Trying to interact with your opponent while using the "board" is painful. And worst of all, I cannot read what anyone is doing because the background of the chat clashes magnificently with the text colour. It has actually made the game unplayable - it takes more effort to figure out what your opponent is doing their turn, then it does to plan out my own turn.
Fix it, or at the very least, revert it back to the way it was.
If this new chat window could be moved and resized, everything would be fine. The thing that everyone hates is that it sits there in the middle of the screen blocking your view of the game. We're getting two sources of data when playing - the chat log and the board - why are you making us choose one over the other?
I also find the new chat window irritating for all the reasons already mentioned. I think making it movable and resizable would solve just about every problem.
I also cannot play since the dancing text is making me motion sick. Props for being the first card game platform to make me motion sick that is an unusual honor.
Letting me move and resize it and stop the dancing would be amazing. Reverting back to what was there before, also amazing.
Please fix it, I want to test my decks!
Ugh can we please have the old chat system back?
Just logging in to express my utter disappointment with the new chat set up.
The dancing text (that resizes) is really difficult to read.
The scrolling down is just crazy (maybe one would get used to that one?)
Having the chat box block the game makes things *very* difficult. I just don't see why this is of any use at all. Chat in lower left (OFF THE BOARD) is great. I don't understand the motivation for this change.
Someone mentioned a "chat ticker". Is that the toolbar-looking thing that periodically shows up between the board and my hand? Maybe that would help, but it is translucent and the text is unreadable. So...that's not working for me at all.
I am currently a subscriber, and I have also contributed to db0's page for netrunner development. I really hope that this chat interface can be fixed.
Thank you for your attention.
Thanks for all of the criticisms that were constructive(not all comments apply). We've made a few updates that will hopefully help. Chat still opens and closes the same way, but in the bottom left. Since you need to focus the chat to close it, you can effectively leave it open by not pressing escape in it.
The current solution isn't the ideal one we wanted, but due to lack of time this is the best we can do for now.
Thanks again for expressing your concerns.
It's way better now, really appreciate the quick fix.
The one apparently remaining issue (at least for me) is that the chat box doesn't scroll down with new messages. Apart from that, this new version seems pretty great (even though it wasn't what was planned).
Summary of problems right now:
1. No autoscroll
2. Retarded amounts of those giant red errors
3. Would be nice if control T still worked, no reason to throw that out
4. Where it was was great, right now it's just obscuring a whole bunch of stuff unnecessarily.
Otherwise, the text links are a nice touch.